Members of the Yavapai College District Governing Board will no longer be allowed to attend executive sessions online after the Board voted 3-1 to conduct all future sessions in person.
“I put this on the agenda mainly because of a situation that we ran up against last week during our exec session,” Secretary and District 3 representative Toby Payne said.
“Exec sessions, on a legal basis, have got to be done in private. Nobody other than board members or those that are part of the discussion are brought into it,” Payne continued. “So because of it, I put this down because of what went on last week, that I feel that all executive sessions in the future for this board should be done in person only, not online, not as a Zoom, only as in-person.”
The vote comes after District 2 representative Deb McCasland allegedly broke an Arizona state statute by participating in the confidential executive session meeting while riding in a car, with other people present in the vehicle.
Arizona Revised Statute §38 431.03.B strictly limits who can be present for the executive session of a legislative body. According to the Arizona Revised Statute, executive sessions “will not be open to the public,” which McCasland allegedly broke when she joined the meeting while in a public setting.
The four members of the board met in-person at the Rock House at the Yavapai College Prescott campus Tuesday, Nov. 11, at 1 p.m., with the session being livestreamed through the college’s YouTube channel.
Members of the board were allowed to give their thoughts on the matter before putting it to a vote.
“I disagree with the motion,” McCasland said. “I was travelling in a car, trying to get my phone to work so I could talk to you and say, ‘I am leaving the meeting.’”
She defended her actions, saying, “with my personal situation, it is very difficult for me to be in person at all of our meetings.
“Nothing was exposed there,” she said. “I was moving, I turned my phone off, nothing was heard. But I can’t attend every session because of personal family matters.”
The biggest concern, as Payne brought up, was maintaining confidentiality under the law.
“You could have given us a heads up,” said Board Chairman Steve Bracety, who also represents District 5.
Bracety said he would have felt “more comfortable” had McCasland disclosed that she was in a car with “other people” and they could have delayed the session until she was “in a more secluded area.”
“That didn’t happen, you took the call, you took the meeting, quite frankly, and other people were listening,” he said.
The board voted 3-1 to move future executive sessions in-person, with McCasland casting the dissenting vote.
Following the vote, the board then moved into an executive session to discuss interview questions and contract for the final candidates for the college’s presidency. The final four, Douglas Berry, Ph.D., Charles W. Lepper, Ph.D., Omar Javier Torres, Ph.D. and Andrew Fischer, Ph.D., are scheduled to visit the Prescott campus starting Nov. 16. After the campus visits, the Governing Board will vote for the next president.
In addition, Bracety congratulated Ryan Jones, who was recently elected to represent District 4 on the Governing Board. He will be sworn in at the first meeting in January.