Tue, Sep

Two years ago, a grassroots effort to end affirmative action in Arizona failed when supporters did not get enough signatures to put the measure on the ballot.

This year, the Arizona Legislature voted to see that voters get a chance to decide the future of affirmative action in the Tuesday, Nov. 2, election with Proposition 107. Proposition 107, also known as the Arizona Civil Rights Initiative, would prevent the state from giving special treatment to or discriminating against someone on the basis of race, sex, color, ethnicity or national origin.

It would put an end to affirmative action created in the 1960s to provide opportunities to groups that had been historically excluded and discriminated against.

A major proponent of ending affirmative action across the United States is Jennifer Gratz.

After graduating high school in 1995 with a 3.8 GPA and a fairly active student resume, Gratz applied to the University of Michigan, but was rejected.

An investigation turned up the fact that the university was giving special preference to certain applicants base on their race.

Gratz sued, and her case went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court where the justices gave Gratz a victory and ended the racial preference program at the school, but only there.

The experience drove Gratz to dedicate herself to trying to fight affirmative action everywhere. Today Gratz serves as director of state and local initiatives for the California-based American Civil Rights Coalition.

She stopped by Camp Verde last week on a tour to share her feelings on affirmative action.

“Affirmative action started out as a good system that was supposed to have no regard for race,” Gratz said. “But it’s morphed into something else.”

Gratz argued that by giving people special treatment due to race and gender instead of treating everyone fairly, affirmative action has itself become a violation of American civil rights.

Supporters of Proposition 107 frame the debate in terms of a fight for civil rights, and Gratz quotes from Dr. Martin Luther King’s speech when he said he wanted to live in a world where people weren’t judged by the “color of their skin but by the content of their character.”

Gratz said with all the other issues that have put Arizona in the news, she’s met many people who didn’t realize this initiative was on the ballot this year.

Affirmative action can be a double-edged sword, Gratz said. Gratz talks about a black woman she met once in her travels.

“This woman, she told me that she had to keep her guard up, that she had to make sure she didn’t have an off day or make a mistake, or else everyone is going to say, ‘Oh, she just got in because of affirmative action,’ instead of her own merits,” Gratz said. “I want to be able to own my accomplishments, to own my future.”

Proposition 107 also has opponents, including the League of Women Voters of Arizona, American Association of University Women Arizona, Arizona Education Association, Greater Phoenix Urban League and the Arizona Public Health Association.

“Prop 107, better known as the Anti-Equal Opportunity initiative, will eliminate important programs that ensure academic success for Arizona’s students,” wrote members of the Arizona Education Association. “Today’s students are the workforce of the future. Without programs that help students learn study skills, access internships and prepare for the workplace, Arizona’s students will fall behind.”

Others worry if Proposition 107 passes, it will set back the efforts of women and minorities after centuries of discrimination.

Diana Gregory with the Greater Phoenix Urban League said this initiative is being stirred up by out-of-state interests who want to make a “test case” out of Arizona.

Other states including California, Washington, Michigan and Nebraska have passed similar measures.

Either way, it will be up for voters to decide Nov. 2.

Yavapai County school districts are signing on to a new forest fee management association to distribute millions of dollars in federal payments to area schools, according to Yavapai County School Superintendent Tim Carter.

Yavapai County School Superintendent Tim CarterThe new association will control how millions of federal dollars will be allocated to schools going forward. The association replaces the Fee Advisory Committee, which historically allocated the funds and admitted the county superintendent as a member.

The superintendent cannot be a voting member of the new association. Yavapai College will also have no vote, a significant change intended to enhance independent decision making to jointly benefit school districts, according to Carter.

The new association will manage a kind of federal tax payment known as forest fees, which are payments due the county each year as required by federal law, Carter said.

Also known as payments in lieu of taxes, the federal program transfers a portion of all money raised on federal lands to counties in lieu of property taxes, Carter said.

The program is intended to make up for property taxes the county is unable to assess on national forest land.

It allows the county to receive a portion of all fees collected by the U.S. for timber operations, livestock grazing, mining, water, recreation and other uses of national forest land.

Forest fees to Yavapai County amounted to $680,000 last year. Previous forest fee payments, reserved by the Fee Advisory Committee, amounted to another $1 million or so.

Earlier this year, the committee allocated $1.4 million of the money to the Yavapai County Education Technology Consortium. The consortium will install and maintain broadband Internet for all county schools, Carter reported.

Most school districts have already signed on to the new, independent association, a move required to qualify for broadband Internet provided by the consortium.

Carter said he agreed with the decision to create a new forest fee oversight group even though it will not have him as a voting member.

Under the former committee’s management, the joint interests of the district benefited. For example, the committee used forest fees to pay for a grant writer who was available to all school districts to help on grant projects.

School districts received a combined $14 million from grants written with the help of the grant writer, Carter reported.

Payments in lieu of taxes to be allocated by the new association could exceed $2 million next year, according to Carter.

The crowd may have not as been as big as organizers would have liked, but it didn’t stop people from keeping the energy level up Friday, Sept. 10, as Camp Verde came together to celebrate the town’s third annual Relay For Life.

More people did start to show up over time, and the people who have worked hard for relay all year spent the night walking a makeshift track at the town’s soccer field.

Bridget Shuflin puts candles into luminarias during the lighting ceremony at Camp Verde’s annual Relay For Life event Friday, Sept. 10. The ceremony was especially emotional this year due to the recent death of a former relay participant, Cathi Fringer, only two weeks prior to the event.Camp Verde’s relay is just one of thousands of such events held annually across the country and internationally, and collectively they represent the largest source of donations for the American Cancer Society.

The fundraiser started in 1985 when just one doctor in Washington state, Gordon Klatt, walked around a track for 24 hours straight. People started coming out to join Klatt’s walk and before long, Relay For Life was born.

The society estimates Relay For Life has brought in around $3 billion in donations over the past quarter-century to help researchers find a cure, and to help those diagnosed with cancer and their families deal with the consequences of the disease.

Of course, the all-night event is just the end to months of fundraising. Most of the money is collected by teams of people who work together against the other teams in the spirit of a little friendly competition.

This year, the local Camp Verde teams were able to raise more than $10,000, event co-organizer Lathana Fulton said.

Particularly impressive was the work of 6-year-old Madison Vines, who raised more than $1,100 of that figure by herself.

“We’ve gone international with the event in several countries, and that’s a feat we’re proud of,” said Tim Carter with the ACS in Flagstaff. Carter said the event’s slogan, “Celebrate, Remember, Fight Back,” perfectly encapsulates the spirit of Relay.

“We want to celebrate those who have survived, we want to remember those who lost their fight against cancer and we want to fight back, all night long,” Carter said.

It’s hard to find anyone who hasn’t been affected by cancer in one way or another, event co-organizer Karen Conover said, whether they’ve been diagnosed themselves or know someone who has.

It was a message that hit especially close to home for one fundraising team. Cathi Fringer, who had worked to raise money with the Choices 4 Life team, lost her battle with cancer last month. A special ceremony in honor of Fringer was held later in the night, along with the luminaria lighting ceremony. Luminarias are traditional Mexican lanterns, consisting of a candle set in sand inside a paper bag. The glowing bags lined the track in honor of those who have fought cancer.

However, Fulton and her fellow organizers like to point out, relay isn’t just about remembering sad memories. It’s supposed to be a good time, which is why the crowd had some help in its all-night mission by a DJ and a series of live musical acts. There were also sandwiches, coffee and cotton candy to keep the energy level up.
Not to mention, there was lots of taekwondo and related acrobatics.

One fellow decided to play the actual part of cancer, dressed in a protective body suit and charging people a buck to kick him.

The survivors also played a big role in the event. After serving as the guests of honor at a special dinner, they took to the field for the first lap to enthusiastic applause. Then came the caretakers, a group Conover said were a special kind of heroes.

Ultimately, organizers of this event and others like it hope that eventually they’ll never have to hold another relay again. But until a cure is found, they’ll soon be busy getting back to work planning next year’s event.

A faulty test cylinder containing 150 pounds of chlorine sprang a leak at a Clarkdale mineral extraction operation, releasing a small amount of chlorine gas, but injuring no one, Clarkdale Minerals Development Manager Tom Piccioli said.

The test cylinder is one of three chlorine storage units located at the plant subject to regular inspections by the U.S. Mine Safety and Health Administration and the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality. Two different cylinders containing potentially deadly chlorine currently operate the plant, said James Murray, Clarkdale Minerals project manager.

The leak was caused Aug. 24 by a valve that was not properly attached to the test cylinder due to defective threads, Piccioli said.

“At no time was anyone in any danger whatsoever,” he said.

The leak was discovered shortly after 7:30 a.m. when a strong odor of chlorine was detected in the experimental area. According to standard procedures in such situations, all employees were evacuated to a central area away from the laboratory, Murray said.

Employees wearing protective gear entered the laboratory with chlorine sensors to verify the leak and then called Clarkdale Fire District to the scene.

“The leak was minor but rendered the building unsafe to occupy,” according to Clarkdale Fire Chief Joe Moore.

The Clarkdale Fire District secured the scene and called in the Camp Verde Fire District hazardous materials team.

Using a special tool for such situations, the CVFD team capped the cylinder within 12 minutes of entering the laboratory. A short time later, the company that originally delivered the cylinder removed it from the scene, Murray said.

Because the leak was so small, Moore decided there was time to call in other agencies to take part in an impromptu training exercise, Murray said.

Verde Valley Ambulance Co. provided medical and rehabilitation services as needed, Cottonwood Fire Department conducted decontamination operations and Jerome Fire Department watched out for the crews on scene.

“In my opinion, they did an excellent job,” Piccioli said.

The primary chlorine cylinders used to operate the plant are located in a separate building. The cylinder that leaked was located in a lab where technicians are investigating new processes to increase the yield of metals from slag, Murray said.

“The two primary cylinders that operate the plant are in full compliance with all state and federal laws,” Murray said. “We have triple redundant alarms that will shut down systems. The building is monitored 24 hours a day. We have not had any incidents” since the company began using chlorine in February.

Located at 500 Luke Lane, Clarkdale Minerals uses chlorine to extract gold, silver and other minerals from the pile, which contains about 20 million tons of material. The pile contains about 0.5 ounces of gold per ton, along with silver, copper, zinc and a ferro silicate byproduct, according to the company’s parent, Searchlight Minerals.

The developers behind a plan to build a 137-condo development along the former Beaver Creek Golf Course have six months to come up with $1.3 million in financial assurances for the project, following a decision last week by the Yavapai County Board of Supervisors.

Yavapai County District 3 Supervisor Chip DavisThe board gave its approval to the plan to divide some of the land for the construction of condominiums in 2005, but the developers are accused of not living up to their end of the agreement with the county, including a promise to make sure there were financial assurances in place.

Ron Schabatka and Seth Williams are the men behind Beaver Creek Land and Water, the corporate entity pushing for the development.

The recent economic downturn didn’t leave the developers’ plan unscathed; the golf course, which was a major cornerstone to selling the condos, shut down along with a popular restaurant near the location.

The stalled project has strained feelings in the community. Many residents have been vocal about their desire to see the Board of Supervisors revoke the permissions in place to proceed with the building of the subdivision.

Many residents have told county supervisors they just want the golf course to be maintained and eventually reopened, and the continued closure of the course has wreaked havoc with their property values.

William Ring, a Flagstaff attorney representing the developers, argued his clients want the same thing — a functioning golf course. Investors in the project argue by shutting down the condominium project, the chances are slim the golf course will reopen anytime soon; they say selling the condos would generate the money needed to reinvest in the golf course.

Other residents, however, told the board last week the developers had no interest in the community, and were stalling on the project until a new buyer comes along to renovate the course.

Janet Aniol, president of the Lake Montezuma Property Owners Association, likened the developers to “pirates,” something Ring vehemently denied.

Another disenchanted resident, John Squire, told the board that for all the concern he believes the developers have for the community, they might as well be “two businessmen from Dubai.”

Others spoke on behalf of the developers’ characters. Joel Gilgoff, a former coworker, described Schabatka as a hard worker and dismissed the talk that he doesn’t care about what happens in the community.

Ring went on to outline what he considers the good-faith progress being made through meetings with the county’s employees at the direction of the Board of Supervisors.

“I personally and professionally resent the characterization of my clients as pirates,” Ring said, arguing it’s next to impossible to engage in any useful or meaningful negotiations with people with those kind of attitudes. His clients have been working diligently as hard as they can to see this project turn into a success that benefits the community.

Kala Pearson, with the Beaver Creek Regional Council, said her group and others have in fact tried to have productive discussions with the developers about residents’ concerns, but their suggestions have been routinely “rebuffed and ignored.”

The issue of revoking the project has been before the board four times now.

The developers argue, in part, the county can’t revoke approval, because some of the lots have already been sold to other parties.

Following an executive session to obtain legal advice and a public discussion, the board voted to give the developers six months to prove they can meet the original stipulations for moving forward with the project, stipulations Yavapai County District 3 Supervisor Chip Davis said the community had originally helped develop.

Until then, Davis said no permits would be issued for the project.

“We need to balance the needs of the community with legal property rights,” Davis said.

With most precincts reporting, Arizona has posted preliminary primary election results. Yavapai County has posted all 112 precincts. Voter turnout in Arizona was 25.21 percent. Yavapai County turnout was 38.2 percent.

U.S. Senate

With about 12 of 15 Arizona counties and most of the other three counties' precincts reporting, incumbent Republican U.S. Sen. John McCain won reelection with 279,173 votes or 56.15 percent. He defeated challengers Jim Deakin, with 11.7 percent or 58,149 votes, and former U.S. Rep. J.D. Hayworth, with 31.92 percent or 158,729 votes.

McCain’s chief contender will likely be Rodney Glassman, who leads the Democratic party nomination for U.S. senator with 84,635 votes, or 34.2 percent. Glassman defeated opponents John Dougherty, with 23.8 percent or 58,898 votes; Cathy Eden, with 26.37 percent or 65,224 votes; and Randy Parraz, with 14.35 percent or 35,499 votes.

They will face Green Party candidate Jerry Joslyn and Libertarian David F. Nolan, who both ran unopposed for their parties’ nominations.

U.S. House of Representatives, Arizona District 1

Incumbent U.S. Rep. Ann Kirkpatrick [D-District 1] ran unopposed for the Democratic nomination and garnered 40,883 or 98.65 percent of the vote.

After a large field of eight candidates, Republican Paul Gosar won the nomination with 19,900 votes, or 31.03 percent. Gosar defeated Bradley Beauchamp, with 15.89 percent or 10,189 votes; Russell “Rusty” Bowers, with 14.46 percent or 9,275 votes; Sydney Hay, with 22.78 percent or 14,610 votes; Joe Jaraczewski, with 2.15 percent or 1,376 votes; Jon Jensen, with 2.46 percent or 1,576 votes; Steve Mehta, with 8.02 percent or 5,142 votes; and Thomas J. Zaleski, with 2.95  percent or 1,894 votes.

The Green Party and the Libertarians did not seek to challenge Kirkpatrick.


Incumbent Republican Gov. Jan Brewer won 400,921 votes, or 81.56 percent, and defeated Matthew Jette, with 3.34 percent or 16,428 votes; Dean Martin, with 6.06 percent or 29,807 votes; and Buz Mills, with 8.73 percent or 42,933 votes.

Libertarian Barry J. Hess won 1,125 votes, or 43.07 percent, and defeated Ronald “Ron” Cavanaugh, with 18.42 percent or 481 votes; Bruce Olsen, with 20.75 percent or 5420 votes; and Alvin Ray Yount, with 7.89 percent or 206 votes. There were 258 write-ins.

Green Party candidate Larry Gist and Democrat Terry Goddard, currently Arizona attorney general, both ran unopposed. They will face Brewer and Hess in the general election.

Arizona State Senate, District 1

Incumbent Republican Arizona State Sen. Steve Pierce will face Democrat Bob Donahue. both ran unopposed and neither the Libertarian nor Green parties fielded candidates.

Arizona House of Represenatives, District 1

Democrat Lindsay Bell will face Republicans Karen Fann and Andy Tobin for two seats in the Arizona House of Representatives. Republican Noel Campbell was defeated in the primary. Neither the Libertarian nor Green parties fielded candidates.

Current tribal chair loses primary, still up for council seat

It’s a two-way race for the position of chairman of the Yavapai-Apache Nation Tribal Council following the results of the Aug. 7 primary.

Great Seal of the Yavapai-Apache NationRoberta Pavatea garnered the most votes for the chair seat with 132 votes. Coming in second for the position was David Kwail with 122 votes. Incumbent Thomas Beauty earned 92 votes while current Vice Chairman Norman Smith earned 72 votes.

Pavatea and Kwail will be facing off for the Saturday, Sept. 18, general tribal election.
Nancy Guzman and Robert Jackson Sr. will be on the ballot running for the vice chairman’s seat. They earned 154 votes and 199 votes respectively.

Beauty will still be on the ballot for a seat on the tribal council, along with 10 others: Laura Cornelius, Billy Garner, Benjamin Jackson Jr., Libby Johnson, Dave Kinsey Jr., Tanya Moore, Dennis Sine Sr., Norman Smith, Carol Williams and Lottie Wilson.

The general election will be held Sept. 18 from 8 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Polling places have been set aside at the social services building in Middle Verde, the community building in Clarkdale and the land and water building in Camp Verde.

Regional fire districts and government agencies have lifted a fire ban that has been in effect for several weeks, but restrictions on burning still remain in unincorporated areas of Yavapai County.

Moisture and humidity played a role in the decision, according to Verde Valley Fire District Chief Jerry Doerkson; controlled burns have been exceptionally difficult to manage.

Many of the districts are following the lead of the U.S. Forest Service.

The Coconino National Forest lifted its ban Wednesday morning, according to spokesman Steve Harper. The Prescott National Forest did the same, along with the Camp Verde Fire District.

 “It’s good to go,” CVFD Spokesperson Barbara Rice said.

Rice added that typical restrictions against burning trash are still in effect.

More Articles ...

Online Poll

Does Thunder Valley Rally benefit or harm Cottonwood?

Verde Valley Weather

Cottonwood United States Fair (night), 47 °F
Current Conditions
Sunrise: 6:19 am   |   Sunset: 6:19 pm
34%     4.0 mph     29.462 bar
Tue Low: 46 °F High: 76 °F
Wed Low: 51 °F High: 79 °F
Thu Low: 46 °F High: 82 °F
Fri Low: 52 °F High: 85 °F
Sat Low: 56 °F High: 85 °F
Sun Low: 55 °F High: 84 °F
Mon Low: 54 °F High: 80 °F
Tue Low: 54 °F High: 82 °F
Wed Low: 55 °F High: 80 °F
Thu Low: 54 °F High: 82 °F