Mingus administrators defend school after Department of Education downgrades

Last year, when the Arizona State Board of Education rated all public high schools in the state of Arizona, Mingus Union High School received a respectable B grade on an A-F scale. In this year’s rating for the 2017-2018 school year, released on Friday, Oct. 5, the school did not do so well. MUHS was downgraded all the way to a D grade.

Mingus administrators have insisted that the drop in the school’s state report card reflects not a change in the school’s quality, but issues with the AZMerit testing process this year. The fall in grade does not affect state funding for the school or similar changes in the school’s programs, but will be reflected in the school’s position in state rankings and listings.

“Our letter grade will not reflect our students’ learning for the 2017-18 school year and it does not reflect the true work of our teachers,” the MUHS administration wrote in a letter sent to parents on Friday. “Therefore, we are in the process of appealing the inaccurate letter grade with the Arizona Department of Education. However, until that appeal is considered, the inaccurate grade will be publicly posted.”

MUHSD Superintendent Dr. Penny Hargrove said that the school’s AZMerit testing last spring had been a fiasco, and that since measures of proficiency and growth in standardized tests account for 50 percent of a school’s letter grade in the Board of Education assessment, the testing issues were the main reason for the decrease.

According to Hargrove, the school had made the deci- sion this past year to condense its three-week schedule for AZMerit testing into just four days of all students testing at once, hoping to limit the disruption of class schedules.

“That first day, all of our students got online, and the system crashed,” Hargrove said. “The next day, we got them all online, and it went good for a little bit, but then it went down again. By the third day, we were able to get the majority of kids on, but they didn’t care any more. If you get in the middle of a test and you lose it all, you start saying, ‘forget this, I’m not even going to try because I could lose it again.’”

Hargrove said that the school expected shortly after the testing that the problems would likely result in a down- grade, but with state regulations requiring all schools to submit their results anyway, and not permitting audits until after the grades were announced this week, the school was left with no choice.

Mingus administrators insisted that even with the abysmal marks the school got on its AZMerit testing, the school did much better in some of the other criteria for the letter grade. Administrators said that graduation rates — worth 20 percent of the rating — actually went up by 15 percent compared to the previous school year, as did college preparedness — another 20 percent of the rating — with more students having completed FAFSA applications, receiving scores above a certain threshold on the ACT and earning industry-recognized certificates than in 2017-2018.

The evaluation in the Board of Education assessment backs up the district’s claims on college preparedness — Mingus got more points in that category than in 2016-17 — but not on graduation rates, where the school received 20 raw points in last year’s evaluation and only 10 points this year, something that MUHS administrators said they were shocked to see when they got the data.

“The graduation points, that surprised me, so either there’s something with the calculation we don’t understand, or we should have received the ten points in graduation rate improvement,” MUHS Principal Genie Gee said. “Having just received the populated information on Friday evening, we need to make sure our school’s data is reflected accurately in the state’s information. I don’t know if it was an oversight, but if it’s something that we need to work on, we’re going to work on it.”

The final category of the report card that was assessed was English Language Proficiency and Growth, which was worth 10 percent of the grade. Administrators said that this year’s score in second language English language and literacy, which was lower than last year’s, reflected real issues in the program.

“We hired an additional teacher to be able to provide leveled classes by proficiency level,” Gee said, referring to the hiring of Julie Heal as a new teacher in the subject. “We hired someone that has a lot of experience in that area and that is specifically what we were looking for in the hiring process — someone who can help us with our systems, some of our processes to make sure we are serving our ELL students to the best of our ability.”

Mingus administrators feel hopeful that they will be able to improve their letter grade on appeal, and have made efforts to ensure that a similar problem does not happen in the next year. The school improved its internet capacity over the summer, more than doubling its IP addresses for both ethernet and WiFi. Administrators plan to run several tests over the course of the school year to ensure that the school is prepared for AZMerit testing.

“The drop is certainly indicative that something happened and we did have something happen,” Gee said. “It’s not representative of what we’ve been doing throughout the year. It’s representative of a tech failure.”

Jon Hecht can be reached at 634-8551, or email jhecht@larsonnewspapers.com

Jon Hecht

Exit mobile version